Motorists must not be hit with a fresh tax raid under pay-per-mile road charging plans, a new report from the Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA) claims.
The report, called Reforming Road Tax: The Case for a Fair, Sustainable Pay-per-Mile System in the UK, by Professor David Bailey of Birmingham Business School, warns that adding mileage charges on top of existing motoring taxes is the “most politically damaging design” for road pricing, and that motorists will rightly see it as an additional tax rather than a replacement for a declining one.
From April 2028, the Government plans to charge electric car drivers 3p for every mile they travel, with plug-in hybrids facing a 1.5p-per-mile charge.
Both will be imposed on top of existing Vehicle Excise Duty. A driver travelling 12,000 miles annually in an electric car would pay £360, rising to £600 for someone covering 20,000 miles.
Plug-in hybrid drivers will be taxed twice for their driving, paying fuel duty on the petrol they use as well as the new mileage charge. IEA analysis shows that, at today’s rates, a plug-in hybrid driver covering 20,000 miles a year would pay £300 in mileage charges. Add the £200 standard VED rate and the £440 Expensive Car Supplement on cars with a list price over £40,000, and the bill reaches £940 a year before fuel duty.
The report warns that taxing electric and hybrid vehicles separately could discourage motorists from switching to cleaner cars, without addressing the wider problems facing road taxation.
Fuel duty raised approximately £24.2 billion in 2025–26, with receipts forecast to reach around £27 billion in 2028–29 before declining as electric vehicles become more widespread.
The report calls for:
- No compulsory GPS tracking: Verify mileage through existing MOT and DVLA records rather than monitoring individual journeys.
- Protections for vulnerable motorists: Safeguard rural households, disabled drivers, carers and lower-income motorists who depend on their cars.
- A fairer tax system: Gradually replace fuel duty with universal pay-per-mile charging for petrol, diesel and electric vehicles, designed to be revenue-neutral for a typical motorist.
- A ten-year roadmap: Treat the 2028 electric vehicle charge as temporary and review universal mileage charging before 2030.
Professor David Bailey, author of the report, said:
“Motorists are already paying substantial sums in tax, and they will rightly be suspicious of any new charge that looks like another way for the Treasury to take their money.
“Pay-per-mile charging could make road taxation fairer, but only if it replaces existing taxes rather than being piled on top of them.
“The Government must also rule out compulsory tracking of drivers. There is no reason why a fair system of road taxation should require the state to monitor where people travel.
“Any reform must protect those who have little choice but to drive, particularly in rural communities where public transport alternatives are limited.”
Richard Holden MP, Shadow Secretary of State for Transport, said:
“Labour’s war on drivers knows no bounds. This is exactly what we warned could happen.
“Labour are getting this whole situation badly wrong. Rachel Reeves started this tax raid and Healey is making it worse. Ordinary drivers will pay the price, and those in the countryside with no bus to catch will pay the most.
“Labour must be honest with drivers about their plans for the future and must stop treating drivers like a cash machine.”
A Honda spokesperson said:
“Honda is fully committed to the transition to sustainable mobility. But the transition will only succeed if customers are confident to make the switch to electrified vehicles.
“Proposals for new taxes on EVs – such as eVED – create consumer uncertainty and risk putting off new buyers.”
Image courtesy of Green Car Guide










